Public SafetySaturday, November 14
Caldwell's mayor advances one finalist in the search for a new police chief
The Daily Caldwell team
If you've been following the search for Caldwell's next police chief, Mayor Eric Phillips has picked one finalist to move forward after Chief Rex Ingram's departure.
Caldwell's police chief search narrowed 17 applicants to one finalist
Caldwell police chief search; recruitment closed Oct. 1, 2026
- Applicants17100%
- Leading candidates318%
- Strongest finalists212%
- Finalist advanced by the mayor15.9%
Source: KBOI
View as table
| Count | Share of the first step | |
|---|---|---|
| Applicants | 17 | 100% |
| Leading candidates | 3 | 18% |
| Strongest finalists | 2 | 12% |
| Finalist advanced by the mayor | 1 | 5.9% |
The recruitment closed Oct. 1, 2026, drawing 17 applicants. Interviews with community representatives and law enforcement professionals left two finalists, and Phillips interviewed both before choosing. Until an appointment is made, the department runs under interim leadership.
“However, we will not rush the process or compromise its integrity.”
- Nov. 16 council meeting: the finalist won't appear
- Council executive session: no date set
- Finalist's identity and evaluators' names: confidential for now
The finalist still has several evaluations to finish
| Step | Who handles it |
|---|---|
| Background investigation | Independent third party |
| Polygraph examination | Independent third party |
| Physical fitness assessment | Independent third party |
| Final interview and questions | City Council, executive session |
Source: KBOI
Phillips said he'll weigh council feedback before deciding when to formally submit the name, and any formal appointment consideration will come at a future council meeting.